• Comment

Grocery store closings leave rural residents with even fewer options

Posted: June 27, 2010 - 12:48am
A man walks past the Turkey General Store, which closed in November. The store's closure in West Texas is being repeated across the country as rural stores struggle to survive amid competition from superstores and meeting delivery mimimums.  BETSY BLANEY
BETSY BLANEY
A man walks past the Turkey General Store, which closed in November. The store's closure in West Texas is being repeated across the country as rural stores struggle to survive amid competition from superstores and meeting delivery mimimums.

TURKEY, Texas - Craig Chancellor tried everything he could, but last November he finally closed the Turkey General Store, leaving the small Texas Panhandle town without a grocery.

Although Chancellor tried to trim overhead and relocated a small cafe he owned into the store, he couldn't make it work. He paid more for salaries and utilities than he made in sales, and finally, lost more than he could afford.

"It didn't play the way we wanted it to," the 48-year-old Chancellor said. "People understand why we had to do it, but they hate it."

Researchers said Chancellor's story is being repeated across the country as rural stores struggle to survive amid competition from distant supercenters and relatively high operating costs. The grocery industry and government don't keep statistics on rural store closures, but experts said a long-running trend seems to be picking up speed. A survey by Kansas State University backed up that belief, finding that more than 38 percent of the 213 groceries in Kansas towns of less than 2,500 closed between 2006 and 2009.

It isn't just a store that goes when groceries close, said David Proctor, who studies rural communities at Kansas State. Such closures rob towns of their vitality, with the loss of gathering places and sales tax revenue to fund local governments.

Once such businesses begin closing, small communities can find themselves in downward spirals, said Kathie Starkweather of the Lyon, Neb.-based Center for Rural Affairs.

"If you start to lose something key like a grocery store, people aren't likely to move there if they don't have access to food," she said.

But Lois Wright Morton, who studies rural communities at Iowa State University, said one reason local markets fail is because residents often prefer to drive to bigger cities with a Walmart, Target or other large store. Shoppers are attracted by generally lower prices and larger inventories.

Another problem for rural grocers, Chancellor said, is that they don't have the economies of scale that bigger stores have and they often can't get food distributors to deliver relatively small orders. He said he couldn't get anyone to deliver bread, so he had to either meet a distributor in a nearby town or buy bread at Sam's Club in Lubbock or Amarillo - the two largest cities in West Texas.

Closures of stores such as his, though, can be particularly hard for elderly and other people who can't drive long distances to big markets.

The 640-some residents of Minneola, Kan. now have to drive about 40 miles roundtrip for food since its store closed. The town's mayor, Carol Sibley, shops for three relatives in their 90s and watches with worry as some elderly residents shuffle across a busy highway to pick up provisions at the only remaining food seller - a gas station convenience store.

"They are just trying to survive and go after groceries," said Sibley whose town boasts of amenities such as a hospital, a nursing home, a bank, a newspaper and a pharmacy.

The U.S. Department of Agriculture calls areas with little access to affordable and nutritious groceries "food deserts."

Thirteen percent of the nation's more than 3,100 counties qualified as food deserts 10 years ago, with most of them in a band of rural areas stretching from Montana to North Dakota and then south to West Texas, according to a 2007 study done by Morton and Troy Blanchard, a Louisiana State University sociology professor.

Farmers markets can help, but crops grown in those communities are often commodities like cotton, not fruits and vegetables, Proctor said.

The federal government is trying to ease the situation with the Healthy Food Financing Initiative. The departments of Treasury, Agriculture and Health and Human Services have proposed spending $400 million a year to bring grocery stores and other healthy food retailers to underserved urban and rural communities to eliminate food deserts within seven years. It isn't clear yet how the money will be split between urban and rural areas.

  • Comment
5
Rating: 5 (1 vote)

Comments (3)

Add comment
ADVISORY: Users are solely responsible for opinions they post here and for following agreed-upon rules of civility. Posts and comments do not reflect the views of this site. Posts and comments are automatically checked for inappropriate language, but readers might find some comments offensive or inaccurate. If you believe a comment violates our rules, click the "Flag as offensive" link below the comment.
0
0

Yeah the mom and pop grab bag

Yeah the mom and pop grab bag days are near bout gone. Bet none of you even remember giving up your nickle just for a chance to reach in a box, pull out a sealed bag with anticipation of a great prize inside. Never mind the candy.

0
0

Texas and National Study on Hunger - 1996-7

This goes along with the study that was funded by R.J. Reynolds Tobacco Company, first in Texas to determine the cause of hunger in the state. Back in 1966, the Child Health Study proved that just getting enough calories was a major reason for nutritional deficiencies, and hunger. The R.J. Reynolds study, about 1996-7, funded 2 Texas A&M post doctoral candidates to work with some of Texas' top concerned professionals. They polled the public about programs such as AFDC, Food Stamps, etc., as well.

The study, first only in Texas but due to interesting variations, move nationally. Residents in many states were randomly polled for their opinion on supportive programs to end and prevent hunger. Interestingly, people in Texas had a more positive opinion about such programs that those in the northern Midwest, and NY, etc. One of our own, now living here, knew the answer to that, so the study on hunger was increased nationally. The reason for the surprising difference -- Texas had the lowest AFDC support payments among all states polled; most states were at least 4X what Texas allowed for a woman with 1 or more children (at that time). Thus, other states' residents’ views of such programs were not as positive as Texans who were spending far less on "the poor."

The final results showed that access to food was the major obstacle, once people had food stamps, or funds to purchase food. In Texas, there are still many counties (lower Rio Grande, for example) without access to food. Most impressive was the inability of people to shop for food safely after dark in municipal neighborhoods; such was the case with many working couples, single parents, etc. who could not leave their homes to shop for food after dark.

Another obstacle was the high price that the local "mom & pop" shops charge for food, many owned by independent grocer chains across the nation positioned in small communities, thus able to charge more for often substandard products. This raises a question: should such markets be allowed to charge such prices, and the federal food stamp program forced to support the costs?

When access to food threatens any community or neighborhood, every effort must be made to stop the threat before it becomes a reality. Every infant, child, and expectant mother who has insufficient calories, much less inadequate nutrients can be permanently affected. Besides serious illness hunger affects learning ability, and causes deaths. Such should be the mission instead of sending our youngsters’ out of the country with church groups to help "others."

With "Wall Street" collapsing the nation's finance market in September 2008 (and other nations' as well) there is less money now to help others - we must help. Each person must become more involved in helping others, and ASKING others if they need help, or food, or clothing, or transportation, or health care, or just someone to help them around the house. Check on your neighbors, your seniors, your disabled.

0
0

Good Article and Good Comments

We need more articles like this that touch on the real issues facing our region. People need access to quality food, quality water supply, quality education, and the availablity of a good general practioner and health care clinic. Most take this for granted, but in small towns and poor, urban neighborhoods these things are often not there.

Back to Top